Must always list inherited item

Description

Must always have inherited or aliased item listed in every row.
1. It needs to be there for comparison.
2. It is the only way to delete an item (eg when only some of a logical group is present, and the values need to be removed).
3. That allows people to vote for "same as parent" as opposed to "explicit value".

That is, there must always be an inherited value (#5bc0de in every row OR an aliased (#ddf value in every row.

Attached are examples of failures to do this.

http://st.unicode.org/cldr-apps/v#/fr_CA/Fields/4e1cdb259b8a680b
http://st.unicode.org/cldr-apps/v#/fr/Fields/4e1cdb259b8a680b

xpath

None

locale

None

Activity

Show:
TracBot
May 9, 2019, 9:54 PM
Trac Comment 12 by —2018-09-27T18:19:48.384Z

I suggest that we close this ticket, since the specific bugs illustrated in the original links for this ticket have been fixed (on SmokeTest). I've opened a new ticket [] concerning the third screenshot ("where we can't delete an item").

There are still many other cases in which a row contains no inherited item. Some rows have no items at all. When is that an error, and when is it just a correct description of the actual situation? For example, recent discussion of ticket [] suggests that it's not an error when a "synthetic" (a.k.a. "extra"?) row has zero items (such as <http://cldr-smoke.unicode.org/smoketest/v#/nl/SAmerica/4abcd3554b48611b>).

There are many other open tickets concerning inheritance, such as [] and [], and I'd like to follow up on the question of when an inherited item is required in the context of those tickets.

TracBot
May 9, 2019, 9:54 PM
Trac Comment 9 by —2018-09-26T19:33:58.490Z

Per today's meeting I've assigned this to myself. The problems shown in the first two screenshots have been fixed, probably by the changes for ticket []. These now show inherited values on Smoketest:

http://cldr-smoke.unicode.org/smoketest/v#/fr_CA/Fields/4e1cdb259b8a680b

http://cldr-smoke.unicode.org/smoketest/v#/fr/Fields/4e1cdb259b8a680b

The third screenshot illustrates a different bug, for which I'm going to open a new ticket.

TracBot
May 9, 2019, 9:54 PM
Trac Comment 8 by —2018-07-22T17:47:03.369Z

This is possibly a duplicate of [], for which a fix [14287] is ready for pushing to production.

TracBot
May 9, 2019, 9:54 PM
Trac Comment 6 by —2018-02-19T14:08:33.394Z

Inheritance may breaks down in some areas. In general, the UI/backend for inheritance needs a end-to-end review.

TracBot
May 9, 2019, 9:54 PM
Trac Comment 1 by —2017-08-21T13:47:00.269Z

Added an attachment showing a case where people (even TC) can't delete an item in the ST.

Priority

blocks-release

Assignee

Thomas Bishop

Reporter

Mark Davis

Reviewer

Mark Davis

Labels

Components

Fix versions